AutoCad vs Illustrator for logo design


Question

I have a customer who says their engineering dept needs a logo done in AutoCad to give him the detail he needs. He says importing an illustrator .dxf file doesn't give him the "quality" that he needs? Has anyone run into this?

1
6
2/6/2015 3:25:00 PM

Most likely he has no clue on how to articulate his needs. What he most likely wants is the vector logo in a usable format. However he is experiencing some problems on the way. I am listing a few problems associated with drafting software export in illustrator, engineering which could potenttially be it:

  • he needs the shading, the export will sometimes only give the edges.
  • most likely he has the reverse problem he wants the outlines, but gets the shading or in fact nothing. This may sound weird but customarily engineers deal with outlines only. So fills may be a alien concept and they can not deal with it. send outlines only.
  • the primitives in illustrator and autocad are different, this causes a bit of problems in conversion. So he might get segments instead of curves.
  • The logo might have round pieces which are NOT circular, that is because illustrator can not really make circles. This may screw up tools that depend on arcs. The circles must be remade, unless you can find a tool to auto fix this (it might exist, long time since i used autocad for day to day business it certainly exists in my CAD.
  • the primitive change might have unaligned edge corners.
  • he is under impression that some dimension is something, the primitive game and adobes calculation precsision might be a problem. Rescale in autocad.

try giving him a v7 eps file instead. Try give him a dwg, or svg file. Worst case you need to get your hand on autocad yourself. Try talking to your engineer and ask him to clarify. Clarifying stuff is his job description.

7
11/7/2014 10:23:00 AM

Licensed under: CC-BY-SA with attribution
Not affiliated with: Stack Overflow
^